Recipes

Caramel Ice-Cream Cookie Sandwich

Posted on Jun 11, 2025 by Macro Mike

  • serves 5
  • prep time 25 minutes
  • cooking time 8-10 minutes

Ingredients

Cookies
1 pktMacro Mike Choc Chip Cookie Baking Mix
60-80mlPlant Milk of Choice
High-Protein Ice-Cream
3/4 cupVanilla Protein Yoghurt
1 scoopMacro Mike Caramelised White Choc Luxe Almond Protein
Caramel
2 tbspAlmond butter
1 tbspMaple Syrup
2 tbspAlmond Milk
Optional Topping
1/3 cupSugar Free Chocolate, Melted
 Crushed Roasted Nuts of Choice

Macros

per serving

  • protein 21g
  • fat 21g
  • carbs 34g
  • calories 414

Recipe by:  @fit_foodie_lulu

Are you looking for the perfect high-protein dessert that tastes incredible? These caramel ice cream cookie sandwiches need to be added to your weekly dessert rotation immediately!🥵🔥🍦


Steps

  1. Preheat oven to 200°C (390°F). In a bowl, mix cookie mix with milk until a thick dough forms. Roll into 10 even balls, place on a lined tray, flatten slightly, and bake for 8–10 minutes. Cool completely on a wire rack.⁠
  2. For the ice cream, mix together the vanilla yoghurt and caramelised white choc protein until smooth and creamy. Pop in the fridge while you prep the rest -  it will thicken slightly!⁠
  3. Spoon 1 heaped tbsp of ice cream onto one cookie. Add 1 heaped tsp of caramel sauce right in the centre. Top with another cookie and press gently until the filling reaches the edges.⁠
  4. Freeze for 1 hour to firm up. Dip one-third of each sandwich into melted chocolate, then into crushed nuts. Freeze again for 30 minutes to set.⁠
  5. Remove from the freezer 20 minutes before eating for the perfect bite.⁠ Enjoy!